The Fresh Loaf

A Community of Amateur Bakers and Artisan Bread Enthusiasts.

Help on modifying a recipe

Paul Cohen's picture
Paul Cohen

Help on modifying a recipe

I recently bought a bread machine and after success with several loaves following directions carefully, I ventured out to modify a recipe.  I had made a loaf of "buttermilk rye bread";  I like a good rye bread but this bread did not really work for me. I liked the texture very much but the very faint rye taste did not seem to me to work.

Having read that rye does contain some gluten, but not very much, I modified the recipe by substituting (for the cup of rye flour) a cup of equal proportions of hazelnut flour with whole wheat flour.  And I omitted the caraway seeds.  The resulting bread tastes great, however the texture is much different than the original recipe and the top of the loaf collapsed; the overall result is satisfactory but not what I expected.  Apparently the new recipe causes the bread to rise more.  Three possible corrections occur to me and perhaps someone can comment on this: 

  1. I need to use less yeast.
  2. I need to use less sugar.
  3. I need to use some different mix of hazelnut and whole wheat flour.  

Then again, maybe the problem is with the caraway seeds or something else entirely.  I'm new to this bread making activity and could use some help understanding what happened.   

Mini Oven's picture
Mini Oven

hazel nut flour contains a large amount of fat.  

Paul Cohen's picture
Paul Cohen

The next time I make the recipe I'll cut back on the oil.  

Mini Oven's picture
Mini Oven

.Recipes for bread machines are very fine tuned and changing them has a lot to do with fitting into the timing set by the machine.  If the substitutions require longer or shorter bulk or final rises it helps to compare recipes. To troubleshoot, more information is needed.  Type of machine, the settings, the recipe. The more info you provide the better we can help.

As a newbie, you may not know the difference between an overproofed or an underproofed loaf easily.  If you can watch the loaf during the process, and report your notes, that too whould help troubleshoot.  It can also be that if you remove the dough after the bulk rise in the machine, you may be able to watch the dough better and eventually  bake in a oven instead of the machine for a successful loaf.  The recipe may work outside the machine. Then again....

Ciarli's picture
Ciarli

 it needs

1cup of strong high proteins white flour,

2cups of rye flour thats low in gluten!